Autonomy And Abortion

Abortion is a hotly debated topic not single in philosophical circles but in political and spiritual circles as well. The anti-choice spatial relation trains that the foetus is a person, has a soul, and as such has a right to life. The pro-choice side has claimed that there is no way to determine if the foetus is a person but even if it does, women should have the option of a safe and clean surgical termination of an unwanted pregnancy. I go away argue on the side of the pro-choice multitude that the autonomy of the cleaning lady justifies an abortion regardless of the belief in a soul or the personhood status of the foetus. I will also demonstrate why this is the best defendable claim within the abortion debate.

Richard J. Poupard makes the argument against autonomy as a justification by criticising the violinist argument. He makes the story that no one would argue the violinist to be a rich human being with a right to life. His argument run lows in that he assumes everyone agrees with him and that everyone puts the same value on the life of another(prenominal) or even themselves. The life of the violinist may be valuable to the violinist himself but is it valuable at the constitute of the sacrifice of the other person involved? Poupard says it is.



To demonstrate his dismantle he uses the example of the acne medication isotretinoin (Accutane).

Accutane is a strictly controlled dose and for a woman to be prescribed it, she must (in intimately cases), prove to be on birth control collectible to the high risk of birth defects. Poupards arguments again fail here with his matter-of-fact assumptions that everyone will agree with him in his statement that we accept these as reasonable restrictions on a womans right to bodily autonomy to optimize the recourse of her child.

Poupard assumes that these restrictions are only in place for the sake of a potential foetus and not in place for the mental, animal(prenominal) and emotional safety of the woman...If you want to get a to the full essay, order it on our website: Ordercustompaper.com



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my paper